
We would love to learn about your project and if you feel The Chameleon Agency might be the right agency to support you. Please get in touch for a no obligations chat to see if we’re right for each other.
Each year, organisations hand large budgets, their brand reputation and their leadership’s stage time to an external events partner. This is just one of the many high-stakes supplier decisions a business makes throughout its lifetime, but in our experience it’s often one of the least rigorously evaluated.
Part of the reason is that events sit at an unusual intersection of relationship and delivery. Unlike buying software or raw materials, events are a personal affair, involving trust, creative chemistry, and often a senior leader who already has a well-established “in” with an agency founder or producer.
Leaning into familiarity or personal connections often feels like the safest option, but while there’s some truth to that, it isn’t the same thing as finding the best fit, and treating the two as interchangeable is a common and costly mistake in event planning.
A large proportion of agency appointments happen not through a competitive process, but through a warm introduction. Your CEO may have already met and engaged in conversation with an agency founder at a conference, or your new marketing director may have their own “black book” of contacts developed from previous roles. Often, we’ll revert to using the same partners for decades at a time, because they’ve never let us down.
Realistically, this is a perfectly rational way to handle things – strong personal and professional relationships engender trust, and when you’ve watched someone deliver before, you have genuine evidence that they can be relied on. Recommendation-based selection also feels lower risk in the moment – nobody’s going to get blamed for hiring an agency that the CEO themselves vouched for.
The trouble is, the safest option isn’t necessarily the smartest, and buyers across every industry fall into a few predictable traps when they choose suppliers this way:
Familiarity leads us to favouring partners we’ve worked with before, regardless of whether or not they’re still the best fit for the brief in front of you. There’s also a case for “availability bias” – defaulting to whichever agency happens to be top of mind, rather than surveying the market properly.
It’s also far easier to stick with current partners – switching just feels too risky, even if performance has plateaued. Lastly, the “halo effect” describes how one great past event, or one charismatic pitch, can colour judgement of everything else a partner might do.
Let’s be clear that none of the above are indicators of bad judgement or leadership; they’re just how decision-making tends to work under time pressure, and they show up in event partner selection as often as anywhere else. The problem is that decisions made this way answer the question of “who do we trust most?”, without ever touching on the more important area to probe, “who is best placed to deliver this brief?”
When a partner is chosen mainly because of who they know – rather than what they can provably achieve – a few things tend to follow.
The brief often gets bent to fit the partner, rather than the partner being chosen to fit the brief. More suitable alternatives may never get a look-in simply because they were never considered in the first place. Accountability tends to soften, too: it’s harder to hold a partner to account on delivery, budget or creative quality when the relationship is doing most of the work, rather than the confines of a contract. Without competitive tension, pricing and scope creep are rarely challenged as hard as they should be, so costs may end up drifting upward over time.
This doesn’t mean the relationship-sourced partner is the wrong choice, and as long as you’re updating your professional relationships as time goes by and the business develops, they’ll often turn out to be the right fit for the brief anyway.
That’s not always the case, though. It’s very common to stick with the same contacts for extended periods of time, without taking into consideration that your business may have outgrown the supplier, or that their service delivery may have changed over time.
The issue, then, lies more in how the decision got made, rather than what the decision turned out to be.
At The Chameleon Agency, we believe the right partner should win the work on merit and creativity – including when that partner is us. A fair, structured process doesn’t have to slow things down or strip out the relationship element. It simply makes sure trust is backed by evidence.
In practice, that starts with the brief rather than the shortlist. Defining objectives, audience, budget parameters and success measures before you think about who might deliver them keeps the comparison honest, and stops the process being subconsciously shaped around one preferred supplier’s strengths.
It also means building a genuine shortlist. There’s nothing wrong with including a relationship-based recommendation, but it’s worth putting two or three other agencies alongside it, sourced through research, referrals outside your immediate network, or a structured RFP.
Every agency on that list should then be scored against the same criteria: relevant experience, creative approach, delivery capability, sustainability credentials, references and cost. A simple checklist works as well as an elaborate scoring matrix, as long as it’s applied consistently – consistency is the key to keeping the process fair.
It helps to separate the pitch from the people who will actually do the work. A strong relationship with a senior contact at an agency doesn’t tell you much about the production team behind them, so it’s worth asking to meet whoever will actually run your event, not just whoever is selling it to you.
References are worth checking properly too. Rather than asking former clients only whether an agency was good, it’s more useful to ask what could have been better, and whether the senior team who pitched stayed involved through delivery or handed the project off.
Finally, involving more than one decision-maker, even informally, tends to counteract the blind spots that come from a single person’s network and preferences.
This isn’t an argument against making (and making use of) professional relationships. After all, the strongest event partnerships tend to become close relationships over time, built on delivery, reliability and shared history. The point we’re making here is one of sequencing: that trust should be the outcome of a good selection process, not a substitute for one.
An agency confident in its own capability shouldn’t need to lean on who it knows to win the work. It should be able to stand up to scrutiny, explain its thinking clearly, and earn the relationship afterwards through what it actually delivers on the day.
That’s the standard we hold ourselves to at The Chameleon Agency – we’d rather compete on our ideas, our team and our track record than on who happens to be in our contacts list, because that’s what tends to produce the best outcome for the business footing the bill.
Looking to engage in a selection process for your next event? Get in touch with The Chameleon Agency for a no-obligation conversation about your brief.
We would love to learn about your project and if you feel The Chameleon Agency might be the right agency to support you. Please get in touch for a no obligations chat to see if we’re right for each other.

Chameleon Agency
Colony, Piccadilly Place,
5 Aytoun St
Manchester
M1 3BR